Ripple’s VP of Litigation: The U.S. SEC ‘Is Wrong on Both the Facts and the Law’
In a recent interview, Deborah McCrimmon, who is Vice President of Litigation and Employment at Ripple, talked about the U.S. SEC’s ongoing lawsuit against Ripple.
As you may remember, on 22 December 2020, the SEC announced that it had “filed an action against Ripple Labs Inc. and two of its executives, who are also significant security holders, alleging that they raised over $1.3 billion through an unregistered, ongoing digital asset securities offering.”
Ripple’s Deputy General Counsel, who joined Ripple as employee #210 (Director of Litigation) around August 2018, made her comments during an interview that was published in Modern Counsel on 17 October 2022. Below are a few highlights from that interview:
- “I learned about Ripple and all their big goals of trying to improve and build and achieve this internet of value. That resonated with me. I wanted to be a part of that.“
- “We have been litigating with the SEC on that issue since late 2020, and we believe strongly that the SEC is wrong on both the facts and the law.“
- “They are reaching far beyond the authority that was granted to them by Congress and trying to regulate a space that Congress never intended them to regulate.“
- “It’s a cutting-edge, industry-defining case. It’s going to be precedential, not just for Ripple, but for the entire crypto industry. It’s being watched by the entire industry.“
Our very own Deborah McCrimmon, VP and Deputy General Counsel here @Ripple gave insight into her experience as a litigator on the groundbreaking SEC lawsuit and how it has been the most interesting work over her 20-year career. Read the full article here: https://t.co/DttUt0e19C— Stuart Alderoty (@s_alderoty) October 18, 2022
One American who agrees with McCrimmon that the SEC is wrong on both the facts and the law is Jeremy Hogan, a partner at the American law firm Hogan & Hogan. Earlier today, Hogan shared his thoughts on the latest developments in the case:
NEW VIDEO!— Jeremy Hogan (@attorneyjeremy1) October 23, 2022
Hinman Emails, Reply Briefs, Oh boy.
We are ALMOST THERE!https://t.co/UAHsB0QwNA
On 21 September 2022, the Ripple CEO talked to Ryan Selkis, Co-Founder and CEO at Messari, at Messari’s annual conference Mainnet (September 21-23, 2022) — in New York City.
Uh oh @twobitidiot brought out the boxing gloves for his discussion with @bgarlinghouse 🥊 😂 This will be fun! pic.twitter.com/Dom5lWMm44— Eleanor Terrett (@EleanorTerrett) September 21, 2022
First, Garlinghouse talked about Ripple’s mission and where it stands today:
“Today, I believe… we are effectively building enterprise blockchain base solutions. We started with cross-border payments. We sell to banks. We sell to financial institutions. We have billions of dollars of transactions going throughRippleNet, through XRP with the product we call On-Demand Liquidity.
“I think Ripple is one of the few truly scaled crypto use cases that actually is solving a problem. It’s not a science experiment. It’s not in a testing phase. If anything, we’re trying to throttle growth right now. The demand is outstripping really our ability to serve that demand right now. In Q2, which was obviously a tough quarter for crypto at large, was a record quarter for Ripple.“
Next, he addressed the misconception that Ripple runs a lot of the infrastructure that powers the XRP Ledger:
“Let’s try to start with facts. So today, of the 155 validators on the XRP Ledger, Ripple runs like six out of 155 or something… There’s been amendments passed on XRP Ledger that Ripple the company opposed. It’s traditional open source software. We can’t control it.“
As for the SEC’s lawsuit, the Ripple CEO had this to say:
- The first time that he went to meet with the SEC, he “didn’t go with any lawyers,” because he did not even imagine that XRP might be deemed a security. And there was “never even a suggestion that XRP was a securit.”
- Ripple is ready to spend even over $100 million to defend itself against the SEC, which he believes is something not just important for Ripple, but for the crypto industry as a whole.
- Back in 2017, Ripple was trying to “sign customer one” (for using XRP in production rather than in a test environment).
- Back in December 2021, when the SEC started its lawsuit against Ripple, “XRP was traded on well over 200 exchanges around the world,” and “99% of all XRP trading had nothing to with Ripple the company.”
- In recent times, the SEC has gone “cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs” (i.e. gone insane) and has been “blasting out these investigative letters.”
- In the first letter that Ripple received from the SEC, which was in 2019, they were told the SEC wanted Ripple’s “voluntary co-operation”, and in fact there was a sentence in that letter saying “we’ve made no determination about what we view XRP as.” However, the SEC claims in its lawsuit that from 2013 to 2023 Garlinghouse “should have known XRP was a security.”
- Ripple believes that there is “no investment contract” and so “you don’t even get to the Howey test.” Neither Ripple or Garlinghouse “enter into a a contract with anyone who bought XRP.”
- By mid November, Ripple should have the motion for summary judgement “fully briefed in front of the judge”, and then it could take between two and nine months for a decision to be made. It is unlikely that the judge will say a trial is needed since there is no real dispute on the facts, only on how the law should be interpreted.
And on October 15 and October 17, Garlinghouse expressed how angry he is with the SEC:
There is no regard for those companies and people that this approach has harmed.— Brad Garlinghouse (@bgarlinghouse) October 15, 2022
We all should be outraged.
The SEC has clearly forgotten that the government works for the people.
The SEC wants you to think that it cares about disclosure, transparency and clarity. Don’t believe them. When the truth eventually comes out, the shamefulness of their behavior here will shock you. https://t.co/rqEzDXEx1A— Brad Garlinghouse (@bgarlinghouse) October 20, 2022