MicroStrategy’s bold embrace of Bitcoin —a core strategy championed by CEO Michael Saylor—has encountered a severe stress test as digital asset prices tumble and the prospect of index exclusion looms, rattling both institutional and retail confidence.
Over the past month, MicroStrategy (recently renamed Strategy Inc.) shares have plummeted over 40%, mirroring Bitcoin’s retreat to multi-month lows under $100,000. The company’s business model, characterized by aggressive Bitcoin accumulation—now at 649,870 BTC worth about $48.3 billion—has been closely intertwined with its market valuation, regularly commanding the so-called “Saylor Premium.” This premium famously positioned Strategy Inc. as a leveraged proxy for Bitcoin exposure, allowing for capital raises through equity and convertible debt that cycle directly into Bitcoin purchases.
But the tide has turned. Bitcoin’s slide from its peak of $126,000 to near $82,000 has not only hammered Strategy’s share price but has sparked questions on dilution and sustainability. The firm’s NAV premium—a linchpin of its capital strategy—has contracted sharply, sparking concern that the rationale for holding its stock over direct Bitcoin ownership may be fading.
The pain may not be over if passive index investors are forced to exit. A looming threat from MSCI, which is considering delisting companies with digital assets representing over half their total holdings, brings fresh urgency to the debate. According to JPMorgan , MSCI’s decision, due by January 15, 2026, could trigger mechanical selloffs of up to $2.8 billion from index funds. If other providers and exchanges follow suit, those passive outflows could balloon to $11.6 billion—15% of Strategy’s market cap—dramatically eroding liquidity and institutional participation.
Analysts warn that exclusion from mainstream equity benchmarks like Nasdaq-100, MSCI USA, and MSCI World would reduce the company’s visibility, complicate future equity and debt raises, and could lower trading volumes. With fundamental profitability now under pressure and its break-even for Bitcoin acquisition close to current market levels, Strategy faces a delicate balancing act.
Despite these warning signals, Saylor remains steadfast, recently assuring media that the company is “engineered to take an 80% to 90% drawdown and keep on ticking.” Yet, whether MicroStrategy’s model remains indestructible is suddenly at the mercy of external index decisions and the volatile Bitcoin market.
The coming months will define if MicroStrategy’s audacious Bitcoin-first strategy is a historic masterstroke or a cautionary tale for corporate crypto treasuries. For now, the battle for index inclusion has put Saylor’s bold conviction under financial microscope, threatening to reshape the landscape for crypto-exposed stocks.
Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Investors should always conduct their own thorough research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions in cryptocurrencies, which are highly volatile and speculative assets.
You might be interested in
